Coconut Oil vs Olive Oil

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosure policy.

Explore the debate of coconut oil vs olive oil. Learn about the potential health benefits and considerations of using coconut oil as a replacement.

Should We Replace Olive Oil with Coconut Oil? | 31Daily.com

Want to save this recipe?

Enter your email, and we’ll send it to your inbox. Plus, you’ll get delicious new recipes from us every Friday!

Save Recipe

Coconut Oil has preoccupied our collective health-conscious consumers for years. It’s easy to find and delicious, imparting a beautiful and distinctive tropical flavor to everything from coffee to popcorn to sweet and savory snacks — to seasonal soups.

Coconut oil is a versatile ingredient that can add a unique twist to a variety of dishes. Whether you’re looking to enhance the flavor of a creamy soup, create crunchy granola clusters, or add a nutty note to your popcorn, coconut oil can do it all.

Coconut Oil Health Claims

The health claims are robust with promises to:

  • slow aging
  • aid heart and thyroid function
  • protect against Alzheimer’s
  • arthritis
  • diabetes
  • aid weight loss

With a plethora of cooking oils to choose from, the question then becomes whether to replace extra virgin olive oil with coconut oil due to its proposed benefits.

Should We Replace Olive Oil with Coconut Oil? | 31Daily.com

What Coconut Oil Is

Coconut oil is made by pressing the fat from the white “meat” inside the giant nut. About 84% of its calories come from saturated fat. To compare, 14% of olive oil’s calories are from saturated fat and 63% of butter’s are.

“This explains why, like butter and lard, coconut oil is solid at room temperature with a long shelf life and the ability to withstand high cooking temperatures,” says registered dietitian Lisa Young, PhD.

Heart Health

Most fans of coconut oil point to studies that show the oil’s ability to boost HDL or “good” cholesterol because it is made of medium-chain triglycerides, or MCTs, a fat that is metabolized more efficiently in the body.

However, boosting the good HDL cholesterol also boosts the LDL or “bad” cholesterol. Nutritionists have argued whether this results in a neutral or even beneficial result. The jury is still out on that one.

It’s important to note that coconut oil has less than 3 percent MCT.

The Concern

Laurence Eyres, chairman of the Oils & Fats Specialist Group at the New Zealand Institute of Chemistry, explains that “butter raises HDL, too, and with coconut oil, ‘it’s particularly the rise in small LDL particles that are worrisome because they are really atherogenic,’ meaning they promote the formation of plaque in arteries.”

The Conclusion

Eyres puts it plainly: ‘It would be dangerous, and rather silly, to replace your extra-virgin olive oil with coconut oil’.”

The American Heart Association says to limit saturated fat to no more than 13 grams per day, which is equivalent to about a tablespoon of coconut oil.

Conclusion: Enjoy the lovely flavor of coconut oil in your food, add it sparingly to sautes and smoothies — or coffee, popcorn… soups, but don’t make it your go-to, everyday oil. Extra virgin olive oil remains the healthiest.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *